Marathon · US

Bonefish Bay Motel

Name: Bonefish Bay Motel
Address: 12565 Overseas Highway, Marathon, FL 33050
Telephone: +1 305-289-0565
Rating: 8.8

8.8

Excellent831 reviews

WiFi availableFree WiFiParkingFree ParkingSwimming poolOutdoor pool

Check-in / Check-out

From 03:00 PM · Until 11:00 AM

Amenities

WiFi available, Free WiFi, Parking, Free Parking, Non-smoking rooms, Air conditioning

Location

Marathon, US

Luxurious Amenities

Bonefish Bay Motel offers free WiFi, a sun terrace, a swimming pool, and a garden, providing a relaxing and enjoyable stay for guests.

Comfortable Rooms

Each room is equipped with a flat-screen TV, kitchenette, private bathroom, and a balcony with stunning garden views, ensuring a comfortable and convenient experience.

Convenient Location

Located near popular attractions such as Florida Keys Aquarium Encounters and Captain Hook's Marina Dive Center, Bonefish Bay Motel is the perfect choice for travelers seeking both leisure and adventure.

Experience the perfect blend of comfort and convenience at Bonefish Bay Motel. Book your stay now for an unforgettable vacation!

Accommodations

Rooms & Suites

Check-in

Check-out

Guests

Loading rooms and rates...

Guest Reviews

What Guests Say

8.8

Excellent

831 reviews

Highlights

+Friendly staff
+Great location
+Good amenities

Could Improve

–Cleanliness issues
–Uncomfortable bedding
–Poor coffee quality

Cleanliness7.5

Several reviews mentioned cleanliness issues including cockroaches and unpleasant odors.

Service9.6

Many reviews noted the friendliness and helpfulness of the staff.

Location9.6

The location was frequently praised for its convenience and quietness.

Room Quality8.6

Rooms were described as spacious and comfortable but some discomfort with bedding was noted.

Amenities9.1

Amenities such as the pool, kayaks, and bicycles were positively mentioned.

Value for Money9.1

Guests felt it was reasonably priced in comparison to nearby areas.

Food and Beverage8.1

There were some complaints about coffee quality.

Overall Experience9.1

The overall sentiment was positive, with a few reservations.

Richard

Couple · Sep 2026

9

Updated rooms and very clean. It was a very nice surprise. Would stay again!

Liked:Great location in the Keys. Extremely clean and updated. The parking is free, Also several extras like kayaks, bikes, etc.

via Nuitee

Donna

Family With Children · Sep 2026

7

Skip this place.

Liked:Room was nice, pool area looked nice, although didn't use.

Disliked:Place not what I expected. They have little homes moved onto property, trailers, etc... just not a good look. You can only use kayaks and bikes certain hours. For what you're paying I expected more. Wouldn't recommend.

via Nuitee

Lily

Solo Traveller · Aug 2026

6

Almost perfect

Liked:I thought the facility was very nice and was clean.

Disliked:I rated my stay a 6 because at first it was clean. The second night we stayed we saw 7 roaches on the walls. We know they werent the same ones because we kept killing them. They were in the bathroom, kitchen and in the bedding area.

via Nuitee

Leah

Solo Traveller · Aug 2026

9

Liked:Wonderful little slice of paradise.

Disliked:Pool was very warm

via Nuitee

Location

How to Find Us

12565 Overseas Highway

Marathon · US

+1 305-289-0565

Policies

Good to Know

Check-in & Check-out

Check-in from 03:00 PM. Check-out by 11:00 AM. Early check-in and late checkout may be available upon request.

Cancellation

Cancellation terms vary by rate. Flexible rates allow free cancellation up to 24–48 hours before arrival. Non-refundable rates cannot be canceled or modified.

Payment

All prices are all-inclusive with taxes and fees. A valid credit card is required at check-in. No additional resort or service fees will apply.

Important Information

Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply. A deposit may be required at the property.

Explore More

Nearby Hotels

Courtyard by Marriott Faro Blanco Resort

9.0/ 10

★★★

Courtyard by Marriott Faro Blanco Resort

2146 Overseas Hwy

795 reviews

9.0/ 10

★★★★★

Isla Bella Beach Resort & Spa

1 Knights Key Boulevard

389 reviews

Faro Blanco Resort Marathon Florida Keys, Curio by Hilton

8.4/ 10

★★★★

Faro Blanco Resort Marathon Florida Keys, Curio by Hilton

1996 Overseas Highway

1,205 reviews

Fairfield by Marriott Inn & Suites Marathon Florida Keys

8.6/ 10

★★★

Fairfield by Marriott Inn & Suites Marathon Florida Keys

13201 Overseas Hwy

1,520 reviews

8.6/ 10

★★★★

Tranquility Bay Resort

2600 Overseas Hwy

904 reviews

7.5/ 10

★★★

Banana Bay Resort & Marina

4590 Overseas Highway

1,375 reviews

Why Dyme

Travel Smarter. Make an Impact.

Every trip you book through Dyme funds renewable energy projects around the world. Same hotels, better prices, real change.

Save up to 35%

Exclusive member rates on 2M+ hotels worldwide

Fund Clean Energy

Your booking directly finances renewable electricity

Price Guarantee

Find a lower rate anywhere and we'll match it

Stay in the loop

Travel deals, sustainability updates, and no spam. Ever.

Accommodations

Rooms & Suites

Check-in

Check-out

Guests

Loading rooms and rates...

Explore More

Nearby Hotels

9.0/ 10

★★★

Courtyard by Marriott Faro Blanco Resort

2146 Overseas Hwy

795 reviews

9.0/ 10

★★★★★

Isla Bella Beach Resort & Spa

1 Knights Key Boulevard

389 reviews

8.4/ 10

★★★★

Faro Blanco Resort Marathon Florida Keys, Curio by Hilton

1996 Overseas Highway

1,205 reviews

8.6/ 10

★★★

Fairfield by Marriott Inn & Suites Marathon Florida Keys

13201 Overseas Hwy

1,520 reviews

8.6/ 10

★★★★

Tranquility Bay Resort

2600 Overseas Hwy

904 reviews

7.5/ 10

★★★

Banana Bay Resort & Marina

4590 Overseas Highway

1,375 reviews

Guest Reviews

What Guests Say

8.8

Excellent

831 reviews

Highlights

+Friendly staff
+Great location
+Good amenities

Could Improve

–Cleanliness issues
–Uncomfortable bedding
–Poor coffee quality

Cleanliness7.5

Several reviews mentioned cleanliness issues including cockroaches and unpleasant odors.

Service9.6

Many reviews noted the friendliness and helpfulness of the staff.

Location9.6

The location was frequently praised for its convenience and quietness.

Room Quality8.6

Rooms were described as spacious and comfortable but some discomfort with bedding was noted.

Amenities9.1

Amenities such as the pool, kayaks, and bicycles were positively mentioned.

Value for Money9.1

Guests felt it was reasonably priced in comparison to nearby areas.

Food and Beverage8.1

There were some complaints about coffee quality.

Overall Experience9.1

The overall sentiment was positive, with a few reservations.

Richard

Couple · Sep 2026

9

Updated rooms and very clean. It was a very nice surprise. Would stay again!

Liked:Great location in the Keys. Extremely clean and updated. The parking is free, Also several extras like kayaks, bikes, etc.

via Nuitee

Donna

Family With Children · Sep 2026

7

Skip this place.

Liked:Room was nice, pool area looked nice, although didn't use.

Disliked:Place not what I expected. They have little homes moved onto property, trailers, etc... just not a good look. You can only use kayaks and bikes certain hours. For what you're paying I expected more. Wouldn't recommend.

via Nuitee

Lily

Solo Traveller · Aug 2026

6

Almost perfect

Liked:I thought the facility was very nice and was clean.

Disliked:I rated my stay a 6 because at first it was clean. The second night we stayed we saw 7 roaches on the walls. We know they werent the same ones because we kept killing them. They were in the bathroom, kitchen and in the bedding area.

via Nuitee

Leah

Solo Traveller · Aug 2026

9

Liked:Wonderful little slice of paradise.

Disliked:Pool was very warm

via Nuitee