Name: Banana Bay Resort & Marina
Address: 4590 Overseas Highway, Marathon, FL 33050
Rating: 7.5

Banana Bay Resort & Marina, Marathon | Member Rates | Dyme

WiFi availableFree WiFiParkingPrivate parkingAccessible parkingSwimming pool

Check-in / Check-out

From 04:00 PM · Until 11:00 AM

Classification

3-Star Hotel

Amenities

WiFi available, Free WiFi, Parking, Non-smoking rooms, Air conditioning, Swimming pool

Location

Marathon, us

Waterfront Resort and Marina

Situated in Marathon, Florida, Banana Bay Resort and Marina offers a picturesque waterfront experience with an outdoor pool and convenient boat docking facilities.

Comfortable Accommodations

Each room is equipped with a refrigerator, coffee-making facilities, and a cable TV, ensuring a comfortable stay for all guests.

Leisure and Activities

Guests can unwind at the on-site tiki bar, make use of the business center and tennis court, and enjoy fishing opportunities. Additionally, the resort's proximity to Dolphin Research Center, Fishermen’s Hospital, and the Florida Keys Country Club provides easy access to local attractions.

Ready to experience a relaxing waterfront getaway? Book your stay at Banana Bay Resort and Marina today!

Accommodations

Rooms & Suites

Check-in

Check-out

Guests

Loading rooms and rates...

Guest Reviews

What Guests Say

7.5

Very Good

1,340 reviews

Highlights

+Great location
+Nice rooms
+Friendly staff

Could Improve

–Poor breakfast
–High fees
–Cleanliness issues

Cleanliness6.8

Multiple reviews indicated cleanliness issues, such as a moldy shower and dampness in the room.

Service8.8

General sentiment indicates friendly staff, but with some issues in communication regarding charges.

Location8.8

The location is repeatedly praised for its attractiveness and proximity to restaurants.

Room Quality7.8

Rooms were described as nice and comfortable, with some mentioning issues like darkness.

Amenities7.3

Facilities including the pool received positive feedback, but the bar and breakfast options were disappointing.

Value for Money6.8

Guests felt overcharged for the services and amenities, with comments on excessive fees.

Food and Beverage5.8

Several reviews mentioned the breakfast as unsatisfactory and lacking variety.

Overall Experience7.8

General sentiment was mixed but leaned positive due to good location and room qualities.

Christina

Couple · Jul 2026

Decent.

Liked:Pool was nice, but no attendant or towels. The sunset area was nice

Disliked:The property needs a major clean up. The Point Bar is not an actual bar with drinks, it’s just a place to watch the sunset.

via Nuitee

Anete

Family With Children · Jun 2026

We loved everything about this hotel. Thank you! :)

Liked:We loved everything about this hotel. Staff was very nice and friendly. Swimming pool was amazing. The best sunset location ever. So nice and calming. Games for kids. Nice hammocks etc. Loved it! :)

via Nuitee

Dorette

Solo Traveller · Jun 2026

DO NOT GO! The hotel does not change the bed sheets between guests.

Liked:Nothing. The experience was terrible. The bed sheets had not been changed from the previous guest. I had to leave the hotel and drive three hours home in the middle of the night with a child rather than sleep in an unsanitary room since they never fixed it. The hotel has not provided a full refund and returned only $10 of a $70 security deposit, even though I never stayed at the property. They don´t answer emails and somehow calls always drop. Do not go there. They are scammers.

Disliked:I’m giving this hotel the minimum rating the system allows me. We came back around 7:00 PM after being told the room was not ready earlier, only to discover that the bed sheets had not been changed from the previous guest. It was obvious that housekeeping had simply straightened the sheets and made the bed without replacing them. They smelled sweaty too. Please see the pictures. I immediately went to the front desk and was assured that someone would come and change the sheets right away. However, by 9:30 PM, after three separate trips to the front desk, nobody had shown up and the sheets were still unchanged. We were traveling with a young child who was exhausted and needed to sleep. After waiting for hours with no resolution, we had no choice but to leave the hotel and drive three hours all the way back home because the room was still not ready for us to sleep in. The lack of care is evident all around the property. The pool area was completely overcrowded and dirty, even with dogs sitting on the pool edge. Many guests were eating inside the pool, playing loud music on their own sound systems, and behaving in a drunken and inappropriate manner in front of children. There were no employees present to enforce even basic sanitary standards or pool rules. Food was floating in the water, including Cheetos and pieces of mango, and some people were even cooking in the area with pots and gas paella burners. Despite leaving the hotel, the manager and staff have not responded to any of my text messages regarding the full refund I requested. I am still waiting for a response. To make matters worse, I was also charged $20 for parking, and they only refunded $10 of my security deposit even though I did not stay at the hotel.

via Nuitee

Crystal

Couple · Jun 2026

poor communication

Liked:nothing

Disliked:everything

via Nuitee

Location

How to Find Us

4590 Overseas Highway

Marathon · us

Policies

Good to Know

Check-in & Check-out

Check-in from 04:00 PM. Check-out by 11:00 AM. Early check-in and late checkout may be available upon request.

Cancellation

Cancellation terms vary by rate. Flexible rates allow free cancellation up to 24–48 hours before arrival. Non-refundable rates cannot be canceled or modified.

Payment

All prices are all-inclusive with taxes and fees. A valid credit card is required at check-in. No additional resort or service fees will apply.

Important Information

A daily resort fee includes a breakfast buffet for two adults, in-room and public area premium FreeB™ Wi-Fi, 2 bottles of water in-room per stay, in-room Keurig coffee makers, swimming pool access, pool towels for resort area use, tennis courts with tennis balls and rackets*, games throughout the resort, 2-hour bicycle rental*, unlimited local and toll-free calls, beach chairs* for use at Marathon beaches, grill and picnic area* and self-parking for vehicles. trailer parking is an additional fee). *available on a first-come-first-served basis. Bikes can be rented for a maximum of two (2) hours. If not returned on time, the rental is subject to a late return fee of $50.00. Breakfast buffet can be purchased for additional registered guests for $11.95 per person/per day. Trailer parking and boat ramp access are available at an additional fee. Additional terms apply. For additional information on Pet Cleaning fee please contact the property directly. Maximum 2 pets (dogs) and must weigh under 65 pounds. Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply. Beds are available on a COME FIRST FIRST SERVE basesGuests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply. A deposit may be required at the property.

Explore More

Nearby Hotels

Courtyard by Marriott Faro Blanco Resort

9.0/ 10

★★★

Courtyard by Marriott Faro Blanco Resort

2146 Overseas Hwy

749 reviews

9.0/ 10

★★★★★

Isla Bella Beach Resort & Spa

1 Knights Key Boulevard

389 reviews

Faro Blanco Resort Marathon Florida Keys, Curio by Hilton

8.4/ 10

★★★★

Faro Blanco Resort Marathon Florida Keys, Curio by Hilton

1996 Overseas Highway

1,156 reviews

Fairfield by Marriott Inn & Suites Marathon Florida Keys

8.6/ 10

★★★

Fairfield by Marriott Inn & Suites Marathon Florida Keys

13201 Overseas Hwy

1,433 reviews

8.6/ 10

★★★★

Tranquility Bay Resort

2600 Overseas Hwy

854 reviews

8.1/ 10

★★

Kingsail Resort

7050 Overseas Highway

2,417 reviews

Why Dyme

Travel Smarter. Make an Impact.

Every trip you book through Dyme funds renewable energy projects around the world. Same hotels, better prices, real change.

Save up to 35%

Exclusive member rates on 2M+ hotels worldwide

Fund Clean Energy

Your booking directly finances renewable electricity

Price Guarantee

Find a lower rate anywhere and we'll match it

Stay in the loop

Travel deals, sustainability updates, and no spam. Ever.

Guest Reviews

What Guests Say

7.5

Very Good

1,340 reviews

Highlights

+Great location
+Nice rooms
+Friendly staff

Could Improve

–Poor breakfast
–High fees
–Cleanliness issues

Cleanliness6.8

Multiple reviews indicated cleanliness issues, such as a moldy shower and dampness in the room.

Service8.8

General sentiment indicates friendly staff, but with some issues in communication regarding charges.

Location8.8

The location is repeatedly praised for its attractiveness and proximity to restaurants.

Room Quality7.8

Rooms were described as nice and comfortable, with some mentioning issues like darkness.

Amenities7.3

Facilities including the pool received positive feedback, but the bar and breakfast options were disappointing.

Value for Money6.8

Guests felt overcharged for the services and amenities, with comments on excessive fees.

Food and Beverage5.8

Several reviews mentioned the breakfast as unsatisfactory and lacking variety.

Overall Experience7.8

General sentiment was mixed but leaned positive due to good location and room qualities.

Christina

Couple · Jul 2026

Decent.

Liked:Pool was nice, but no attendant or towels. The sunset area was nice

Disliked:The property needs a major clean up. The Point Bar is not an actual bar with drinks, it’s just a place to watch the sunset.

via Nuitee

Anete

Family With Children · Jun 2026

We loved everything about this hotel. Thank you! :)

via Nuitee

Dorette

Solo Traveller · Jun 2026

DO NOT GO! The hotel does not change the bed sheets between guests.

via Nuitee

Crystal

Couple · Jun 2026

poor communication

Liked:nothing

Disliked:everything

via Nuitee