Udaigarh

Generally clean rooms and bathrooms noted, but occasional issues reported (pool water seemed unclean to some, pigeon droppings around pool area, and a couple of mentions of drain smells).

Staff frequently described as friendly, helpful and attentive with standout service for special occasions, though a few mentions of limited interaction and one incident with unsealed water bottles.

Excellent lakeside location with superb rooftop views, under 10 minutes' walk to City Palace and very convenient for exploring the Old City.

Rooms are nicely decorated but mixed quality: some guests noted firm or springy mattresses, rooms without full windows or dark ground-floor rooms, and occasional bathroom drainage odors.

Strong rooftop restaurant and pool that elevate the stay; however there are reports of pool cleanliness concerns and espresso being charged despite breakfast inclusion.

Many guests felt they received great value for money given the views, service and facilities, though a few noted that slightly pricier nearby hotels could be better for some preferences.

Breakfast and restaurant repeatedly praised as excellent, adding to the experience; minor negatives include paid espresso and isolated quality concerns.

Overall very positive and often memorable stays (anniversaries, exceptional reviews) driven by location, rooftop views and service, with a few practical issues noted.